2012: Plummer finished third on the team in scoring in her only season with the Express. She was named Second Team All-Region XII following the season due to her five goals and seven assists. She finished second on the team in assists, and fifth in goals scored.

Following the season, Plummer signed with Tiffin University.

Prior to Owens: Plummer transferred to Owens following her freshman year at Baldwin Wallace University, where she saw action in 13 games and attempted two shots with one on goal.

She was a four-year starter at Lake HS in Millbury, OH for coach Steve Hoffman. As a sophomore, Plummer was named the Suburban Lakes League (SLL) Player of the Year after scoring 22 goals with five assists. Additionally, she was named First Team All-SLL and D-II First Team All-District as a sophomore and junior, while being named Second Team All-Ohio as a junior. Also as a junior, Plummer helped lead the team to an appearance in the regional championship game. As a senior, she helped lead the team to the district semifinals while garnering Honorable Mention All-SLL honors. Plummer also earned Honorable Mention All-SLL honors as a freshman.

Plummer, who set school records at Lake for most career goals (53) and most assists in a career (19), also played basketball at Lake, where she earned Second Team All-SLL honors as a junior.

Personal: Plummer is the daughter of Allen and Tonya Plummer. She has two brothers - Damon and Dylan.