1999 season: Kistner was fourth on the team with a .322 batting average. In 118 at bats, she had 23 runs, 22 singles, eight doubles, five triples, a team-high three home runs, 17 RBI, 11 strikeouts and five walks. She was Honorable Mention All-OCCAC, an NJCAA Academic All-American and an All-OCCAC Academic Team selection.

High School: Kistner was First Team All-SLL and First Team All-Wood County as a senior, and Honorable Mention All-SLL and Honorable Mention All-Wood County as a junior.